After I published The Story of You, I was in need of a positive and fun distraction (and, admittedly, a way to promote the book during holiday season — a task I usually dread). I started out just looking around for Swiftie gift ideas that would be unique and high-quality. (Since The Eras Tour there’s been a lot of not-so-great products made for fast cash grabs, and Swifties deserve better than that!) And as I was looking, I realized it would be really fun to put together a little gift guide for each Taylor Swift era so you can find what’s most likely to appeal to you (or the person you’re shopping for).
I did my best to showcase small creators and lesser known businesses, but you’ll see some big names like Amazon in there, too. (The Amazon links are affiliate links, so if you click those, you’re also supporting Positively Present.) I’d like to expand the list, so if you know if any gift ideas that would be perfect for a specific era but aren’t listed (especially if they’re made by a small creator!), let me know and I’ll keep adding to the list of gift ideas. (I also made an Ornament Guide with ornaments for every song, so check that out if you like this!)
Debut
The Story of You
Ready For It! 2026 calendar
Cirque nail polish
Cowboy boot match striker
Pink phone pin
Retro bluetooth speaker
Truck ornament
Daisy pillow
Debut magnet set
Georgia Stars tee
Debut pen set
You’re Gay patch
Robert Frost book
Tim McGraw CD
Cowboy crossbody purse
Ukulele stuffed animal
Cowboy boot keychain
Taylor Swift By the Book
Butterfly string lights
Fearless
The Story of You
“Fearless” lyric ornament
Fearless Eras t-shirt
Million Stars ornament
Prettiest Lady mug
Heart Hands bookends
“The Best Day” onesie
Fearless necklace
Romeo & Juliet
Heart hands patch
Fearless candle
Guitar necklace
Fearless era charm bracelet
Junior Jewels sticker
Phone ornament
“Forever & Always” ornament
Speak Now
The Story of You
Purple card deck
Notecards (for writing John)
Firework matches
Long Live canvas sign
Speak Now sticky notes
Dragon stuffed animal
Baggu cosmetics case
Purple string lights
Electric Guitar ornament
Swallow ornaments
Long Live sweatshirt
Next Chapter! bookmark
Dragon trinket tray
I Can See You ornament
Timeless ornament
Keep Making Art pen
Wonderstruck pin
Fighting dragons sticker
Red
The Story of You
Falling leaves ornaments
Lost Upstate t-shirt
22 T-shirt mug
Red scarf
Knew You Were Trouble doormat
Fox scarf ornament
Burning Love lighter
“Begin Again” pin
Neruda love poems
Autumn leaves sweatshirt
Red necklace
All Too Well film car print
Holy Grounds sticker
James Taylor album
Crumpled tissue holder
NARS Dragon Girl lip pencil
Mosaic Heart ornament
Message In A Bottle ornament
Sagittarius frame
“All Too Well” scarf patch
1989
The Story of You
MAC Red lipstick
Seagull ornament
New Romantics sticker
Seagull cloud phone case
Cherry Skies pillow
NYC Skyline model
Polaroid camera
Taylor Swift Style book
Paper airplane necklace
Alice in Wonderland tarot deck
Wildest dream key
Pink flamingo tray
NYC Apple ornament
Kendrick Lamar GNX CD
Cheshire Cat book pin
Ace cards ornament
1989 Crystal Skies pin
TS Cheer sticker
reputation
The Story of You
Big Reputation pen set
Own Him Nothing necklace
Witches mug
Snake stuffed animal
123 LGB sticker
Stumble Home to My Cats glass
“Getaway Car” license plate
Gorgeous cocktail print
Old Taylor patch
Snake barrette
Rep sweatshirt
The Great Gatsby
Old Fashioned notecards
Marc Jacobs rep vibes purse
It’s Delicate sticker
“New Year’s Day” lyrics ornament
King of Hearts ornament
Rep camera pin
Lover
The Story of You
Miss Americana matches
“Afterglow” keychain
London bus ornament
Stoplight charm
The Archer sweatshirt
Swan hairbrush
Bunny Cherub print
Shiny Rings puzzle
Paper Rings ring dish
Squashies candy variety pack
“New Romantics” sticker
Cupid Cat art print
Cornelia Street patch
The Lovers tarot pendant
Lover house ornament
Rainbow ornament
“Daylight” lyrics button
“Cruel Summer” hair clips
Lover House building blocks
folklore
The Story of You
MAC Black lipstick
Old Habits t-shirt
Wonderball Magic 8 ball
This is Me Trying hat
Disco Ball planter
Saturn earrings
Cardigan ornament
Invisible Strings book
Mirrorball cat print
Scorpion stud earrings
Rebecca book
American Dynasty newspaper print
“The 1” journal
“This Is Me Trying” print
“This Is Me Trying” pen
Hope of It All sticker
Moon & Saturn cat button
Wordsworth poems
evermore
The Story of You
Sagittarius hair pin
Olive Garden gift card
Pots and pans ornaments
Beer candle
Plaid hand towels
“Tis the Damn Season” greeting card
Girl in Delusion t-shirt
“Tolerate It” tote bag
Willow Cat ornament
Emily Dickinson poems
“Ivy” stained glass print
Champagne gummies
“Tolerate It” painting print
“Willow” x “I Know Places” pin
The Fancy Shit patch
Rearview mirror sticker
“Willow” enamel pin
Still at the Restaurant sticker
Evermore spiral notebook
Midnights
The Story of You
I’m the Problem pillow
Pat McGrath eyeliner
Lavender incense set
Gold clock ornament
Jewel ornaments (more colors!)
Midnight Musings sticky notes
What Goes Around yarn sticker
Vote for Me button
Sapphire Tears ring
Starry sky crossbody purse
3-in-1 game set
Breathe pencils
Ghost coasters
“Dear Reader” bookmark
Clock coffee cup patch
Midnights clock
Too Soft sticker
The Torture Poets Department
The Story of You
Modern Idiot mug
Female Rage tote bag
Typewriter pen holder
Buckingham Nicks album
Just Kids by Patti Smith
Clara Bow book
Blue Nile album
Cinephile chocolates (6 bars)
Tortured Poets bracelet
I Cry A Lot cap
Dylan Thomas poems
Circus Tent trinket box
Tortured poet pin
Lights Camera patch
Tough Kid necklace
TTPD: The Anthology
The Story of You
American Pie DVD
Go Get ‘Em Tiger banner
Cassandra book
Peter Pan ornament
Peter Pan book
Aristotle bust
Albatross vintage print
Secret Gardens bookmark
Robin stuffed animal
“I Hate It Here” cake pin
Bolter license plate
Wendy by the Window pin
Albatross Cardigan sticker
“Thank You Aimee” sticker
“So High School” sticker
The Life of a Showgirl
The Story of You
Expensive Energy notepad
Showgirl pen
Evil Eye trinket dish
Eldest Daughter crewneck
ILNP orange polish
Orange evening bag
Rare Beauty highlighter
Red Crystal earrings
Superstar baby tee
Showgirl Era necklace
Shiny Bug stud earrings
Furious Love book
Tom Ford Vanilla perfume
Pat McGrath red lipstick
Ophelia pin
Ticket stub organizer
Pierced Heart ornament
Miscellaneous Swiftie Gifts
The Story of You
Eras nail stickers
Cowboy boot ornament
Swift Affirmations pen set
New Heights hoodie
Eras ornament set
Listen to Taylor Swift air freshener
Taylor Eras card game
My Mind is Alive keyring
NARS Morocco lipstick
Track 5 Girlie pin
Swiftie Gift Packs (pins & keychain)
Taylor Tic Tac Toe
Eras matches print
Taylor’s Stars button
Eras spiral notebook
Swiftie Circle ornament
Whether or not you celebrate Christmas, I hope you enjoyed looking through all of these gift ideas and seeing some Taylor Swift holiday inspiration. Be sure to check out the Ornament Guide, too!
If you’re a Swiftie (or looking for a Swiftie holiday gift!), check out my new book, The Story of You: A Swiftie Journal & Coloring Book for Self-Discovery. In it, you’ll find Taylor Swift-inspired inspiration and introspection carefully chosen (and illustrated) by me to help you on your self-discovery journey. Available wherever you like to buy books or here.
As I was working on these gift guides, I started finding more and more ornaments that would fit with specific Taylor Swift songs. So I decided (like a lunatic, haha) to find an ornament for every single song. It took awhile and lot of searching, but I did it! You can check out the ornaments for each song here.
No products in the cart.